Pels Pie Co.

Pels Pie Co.

Cooking
Lefferts Garden, Brooklyn, New York
(44 Reviews)

It has been a delight and a challenge to bring fresh pies to Prospect Lefferts Gardens since March 27, 2015.
 
We have taught ourselves to bake better every day and grow with the palettes of the best set of regular customers in the city, and respond enthusiastically to that ever present question:
 
"What do I want to eat?"
 
Everything is made from scratch and even the most decadent of treats are wholesome. We offer the best coffee by Counter Culture Coffee and the best tea (in our giant mugs) by Kusmi Tea, and always try our best to bring local and exotic wine and beer to make your day even better.

Reviews of Pels Pie Co.

(44 Reviews)
Pie Making

10/10/2019
Meghan F.

Attended: Pie Making


I had a terrific experience and can't recommend it highly enough. Allison at Pels Pie Co. has created an authentic, warm, neighborhood atmosphere and she is a terrific teacher. She put me at ease and I am thrilled with the pie I learned how to make. I can't wait to revisit Pels Pie Co. and bring friends with me. My class was one on one which was great fun, but this experience is also perfect for a girls night out or a date.

Pie Making

8/16/2019
Arthur B.

Attended: Pie Making


It was great fun and Alison was terrific. I learned a lot of extra wonderful little tips. It was a pretty special evening

Pie Making

6/26/2019
Nahid A.

Attended: Pie Making


The chef was very good ...a lot of tips and good atmosphere

Pie Making

6/3/2019
Amanda F.

Attended: Pie Making


Alison was so wonderful and welcoming! I appreciated her approach to pie making—use your hands for as much as possible—and together we made a delicious strawberry and rhubarb pie. The pie is by far the best one I've made. I shared it with friends just after baking it and they all agreed, the best pie I've ever made. It was quite a Sunday evening treat. The bakery is cozy and clearly a neighborhood anchor. Everyone was joyful, saying hello to one another and enjoying the day. I would definitely recommend this class to anyone looking to improve their pie making technique, enjoy a hands-on afternoon learning something delicious, or to a group of friends who want something unique to do together. I'll definitely be letting friends know to come by Pels for a slice or to take a class.

Pie Making

5/15/2019
Kathryn M.

Attended: Pie Making


Alison was so great and gave us really good tips for pie making. Highly recommend the coconut custard pie! Reminds me of the filling of a mounds bar. We also got to take home leftover dough for making two additional pies.

Pie Making

5/12/2019
Lauren G.

Attended: Pie Making


Alison was very friendly, skilled, and a great teacher! My pie came out awesome! I really enjoyed myself.

Pie Making

5/12/2019
Kelsey O.

Attended: Pie Making


Alison was such an incredible instructor, we learned a lot and had a really fun Saturday evening! She was great at explaining while demo-ing and then offering helpful instruction while we replicated the process. She was really patient and not the least bit bothered when our pies took 30 extra minutes to cook beyond the class end time (and she had lots of baking still to do for Mother’s Day). We loved the ambiance of the shop as well, it’s clear she has many regulars for a reason. I highly recommend this class to everyone of all levels and will definitely return to her shop to sample more of her professional creations soon!

Pie Making

3/28/2019
Dylan R.

Attended: Pie Making


This was such a chill, fun class! Alison was so great, so informative, and she let us choose the kind of pie we wanted to make! She made the whole process so simple and easy to remember, and then we got to take our pies home in a reusable baking dish that I definitely plan on putting to work! I highly recommend making the pear-almond pie, I’ve had it for breakfast every day since the class and it is *chef’s kiss* just the best.

Pie Making

3/11/2019
Richard B.

Attended: Pie Making


great experience, great date idea

Pie Making

2/24/2019
Joe W.

Attended: Pie Making


Great fun and would recommend for anyone. Pies tasted great and we'll be making more

Show More Reviews
Questions about this school?
446 Rogers Ave, Brooklyn, New York 11225
Pels Pie Co.
Lefferts Garden, Brooklyn
446 Rogers Ave
At Lincoln Rd
Brooklyn, New York 11225

Upcoming Classes at Pels Pie Co.

Pie Making
Pie Making
Next start date:

Wednesday Oct 23rd, 7pm - 10pm

Teachers at Pels Pie Co.