Benaifer began her storytelling journey in the Munirka slums of Delhi, listening to the stories of women as they struggled to better their lives. She earned her Masters Degree in International Affairs and Social Work from Columbia University and has worked as a clinical social worker, human rights activist, and community organizer. She has fostered the storytelling of pregnant teenagers in the Bronx, sex workers from South-East Asia, gay men facing discrimination from their own governments in Southern Africa, and transport workers fighting the stigma associated with HIV and AIDS in Kenya. As a teacher, Benaifer continues this work by helping to create safe spaces where students may find their voices and be inspired to listen, share, and connect to others through their stories.